Asked to Give Advice? Don’t Feed. Give Food for Thought.

When you’re looking for advice, would you rather have someone tell you what to do? Or would you prefer that they give you things to think about so you can decide for yourself?

There’s a nuance here that’s worth breaking down and an approach worth sharing – an approach my mom taught me.

Quick story. A friend was preparing for a panel interview for a role she desperately wanted. She asked me to take a look at the questions she was asked to cover and an outline of the points she planned to make.

As I read her outline, I felt something was missing. I thought about what I would want to hear if I were on the interview panel, and what I read didn’t quite do it.

I didn’t want to put words in her mouth, or in her document.

I didn’t want to edit her outline, hard as it was to not enable track changes.

I didn’t want her to feel demoralized or that she needed to start all over again.

I wanted her to give feedback in a way that she would feel supported and encouraged.

And I wanted her to get the job!

Instead of telling her what to do, or what I would do, I did what my mom would have done.

1.) Clarify what the problem, challenge or dilemma is.

2.) Ask if I’m open to feedback.

3.) Give the feedback as something to think about, not a directive or advice per se.

4.) Offer to be available to circle back and/or hear how it went.

My mom used to do this all the time. She shared her point of view, experience, knowledge, and wisdom. The rest was up to me. Mom was so smart. She would usually end our chats by saying this:

“You heard my two cents. You’re a grown woman.
You do what you THINK is best.”

Corona Panzano, Mom

How empowering!

She didn’t feed me. She gave me food for thought.

I’ve recently been the recipient of an approach like this, and it reminded me of how powerful and effective it is. I just used it with my friend. She got the job.

Next time you are asked for advice, consider this:  don’t feed them; give them food for thought.

To Your Prosperity!

If you’re interested in learning more about how I can help you and your team prosper, let’s talk.

Let’s Talk – Help People Prosper

About the Author:  Mary Lou Panzano

Mary Lou Panzano is an award-winning communications executive with over 35 years of experience in employee communications at global companies, empowering leaders to guide strategic organizational change. As Founder and CEO (Chief Enlightenment Officer) of Panzano Enterprises, LLC, Mary Lou focuses on empowering leaders to not just navigate change more effectively, but prosper through it.

She is a certified leadership coach, speaker, best-selling author, and communications advisor passionate about helping people succeed through any change they want to make in their business or lives. Mary Lou just released her first solo book, Cementing Change: Cracking the Code for Communications that Work. She is also a featured author in the Cracking the Rich Code, Volume 18 anthology and a contributing author in The Art of Connection: 365 Days of Resilience Quotes by Entrepreneurs, Business Owners and Influencers.